Best Firearms: A Practical Guide
Choosing the best firearm isn’t about finding a single winner; it’s about matching the right tool to a specific job. A $3,000 competition pistol is a terrible choice for a backpacking survival kit, just as a .22 LR plinker is useless for stopping a bear. Here’s a breakdown of top-tier options for core shooting disciplines, based on reliability, performance, and real-world use.
The Definitive Defensive Handgun: Striker-Fired 9mm
For modern personal defense, the striker-fired 9mm pistol is the standard. The Glock 19 Gen 5 remains the benchmark for its perfect balance of size, 15+1 capacity, and legendary reliability. Its consistent 5.5-pound trigger pull and lack of external safeties make it simple under stress. The Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 is a direct competitor, offering an excellent grip texture and a crisper trigger out of the box. For those who prefer a hammer-fired option, the Sig Sauer P226 in 9mm is a combat-proven workhorse, though its all-metal frame makes it heavier. All three platforms have massive aftermarket support. At Americans Gun, we consistently see these models lead the handguns collection in sales because they simply work when it matters.
The Ultimate Rimfire Trainer: Ruger Mark IV 22/45
Mastering fundamentals requires thousands of repetitions, and nothing facilitates that like a .22 LR pistol. The Ruger Mark IV 22/45 Lite is the pinnacle of this category. Its 1911-style grip angle trains muscle memory for centerfire shooting, while the one-button takedown makes cleaning trivial compared to previous Mark series models. The aluminum Lite upper keeps weight down, reducing fatigue during long training sessions. It’s incredibly accurate, eats all types of ammo, and with a suppressor, it’s nearly silent. For developing shooters or seasoned pros maintaining skills, this is an indispensable tool. We stock it because it’s the best in its class.
The Do-All Modern Sporting Rifle: AR-15 in 5.56 NATO
The AR-15 platform is the most versatile firearm an American can own. A quality 16-inch carbine in 5.56x45mm NATO serves for home defense, varmint control, competition, and training. The key is in the build: a cold hammer-forged barrel from FN or Daniel Defense, a mil-spec bolt carrier group, and a free-float M-LOK handguard. Brands like BCM (Bravo Company Manufacturing) and SOLGW (Sons of Liberty Gun Works) build rifles to rigorous duty standards. Pair it with a red dot sight like the Aimpoint PRO and a weapon light, and you have a capable system for most scenarios under 300 yards. Its modularity is its strength, allowing endless customization from our firearms collection of parts and accessories.
The Hard-Hitting Hunting Rifle: Bolt-Action in .308 Win
For taking game ethically at distance, a bolt-action rifle is the hunter’s choice. The .308 Winchester cartridge is the ideal balance of power, availability, and manageable recoil, effective on deer, elk, and bear within 500 yards. The Tikka T3x Super Varmint, with its heavy barrel and superb out-of-the-box trigger, offers exceptional accuracy. For a more traditional sporter, the Winchester Model 70 is a timeless “Rifleman’s Rifle” with a controlled-round feed action. Modern offerings like the Bergara B-14 HMR provide Remington 700 compatibility with upgraded barrels and actions. These rifles demand quality optics; a 3-9×40 or 4-12×50 scope from Leupold or Vortex is the standard pairing. Proper ammunition, like the Thompson Center Sure Fire Sabots for muzzleloaders, is equally critical for precision.
Specialized Tools: Shotguns & Muzzleloaders
Specific tasks demand specialized tools. For home defense and bird hunting, the 12-gauge pump-action shotgun is king. The Mossberg 590A1, with its metal trigger guard and safety, is built for hard use. For clay sports, an over/under like a Browning Citori or a semi-auto like a Beretta A400 dominates. In states with primitive weapons seasons, a modern inline muzzleloader is essential. The Thompson Center Pro-Hunter system, for which we carry specific parts like the Pro-Hunter breech plug, allows hunters to extend their season with a powerful, accurate .50-caliber option. Even air rifles have a place; the Crosman Comrade AK Air Rifle provides low-cost, backyard tactical training.
What is the best all-around first firearm?
A 9mm striker-fired pistol like a Glock 19 or Smith & Wesson M&P9 is the most practical first purchase. It’s suitable for home defense, can be carried concealed with proper training and licensing, and 9mm ammo is affordable for practice. Master this platform first.
Is a .22 LR worth buying for an experienced shooter?
Absolutely. A high-quality .22 LR like the Ruger Mark IV is the most cost-effective training tool you can own. It allows you to practice trigger control, sight alignment, and marksmanship fundamentals for pennies per round, preserving skills between centerfire sessions.
How much should I spend on a hunting rifle?
Plan to spend at least $600-$800 on the rifle itself (e.g., Tikka T3x, Bergara B-14) and an equal or greater amount on a quality scope, rings, and base. A $1,000 rifle with a $100 scope is a $100 rifle. Invest in the optics and ammunition like specialized projectiles for your discipline.
Browse our firearms collection
Last updated: March 28, 2026